Trading this top Astros prospect would wreck everything that Houston is building

As the Houston Astros hurdle towards the trade deadline, battered and bruised, the club will be scouring the market for reinforcements as they look to capitalize on their incredible first half that defied expectations.

With Jeremy Peña still out of action, top prospect Brice Matthews got called up to solidify the middle infield after a scorching showing at Triple-A Sugar Land, posting a .283/.400/.476 line. However, Peña isn't expected to dwell on the injured list for much longer, leading some to question if Matthews is long for the big league roster.

At the same time, Houston has a plethora of roster needs that must be addressed by the July 31 deadline. With a sparse farm system, Matthews could come into the crosshairs of a rival in trade negotiations.

Trading Brice Matthews would upend everything that the Astros have been working towards

When Houston traded away Kyle Tucker, much of the baseball world chided the club for not maximizing on its window of contention, even if the return was near-universally lauded. When the Astros failed to reunite with home-grown star Alex Bregman in free agency, proclamations of their demise became commonplace amongst the punditry.

But Dana Brown and the rest of Houston's top brass have a vision for how this is all going to play out. They are trying to thread the needle, walking a fine line between contention and positioning themselves for a brighter future.

After so many years contending, attrition has taken it's tool on the farm system as prospects have gone out to quench the desires of the big league roster, success has led the Astros to picking late in drafts, and of course the Astros' talent pipeline was further damaged as a result of the penalties levied against them from the 2017 sign-stealing scandal.

Entering the season with little more than Jose Altuve as the vestige of a dying dynasty, Houston looked to be in for a long and painful rebuild sooner rather than later. However, as this season's success has shown, a budding new core is taking hold in the Space City.

Cam Smith is a Rookie of the Year candidate. Hunter Brown is now one of the best pitchers in all of baseball. Isaac Paredes earned a well-deserved All-Star selection this year. Jeremy Peña's emergence as a superstar is for real.

Houston has its next great core forming, but more is still needed. Brice Matthews is the lone piece who is head and shoulders above the rest, and stands to join these aforementioned players as the foundation for the next great Astros' run.

So while Houston will need to dip into their old bag of tricks in order to keep the good times rolling in 2025, they need to tread carefully. If they play things right, they can seriously compete in October while avoiding the painful valley that comes when a team ages out of its run of dominance.

Prospects will be moved for reinforcements at the deadline, but Houston is teetering on the brink of bridging the gap between their past dominance and the creation of a potential future juggernaut. Brice Matthews has proven nothing at the major league level yet, but his talent and potential make him a critical piece that can make this gambit pay off.

Trading Matthews now would signal that everything Houston has been working to build is for naught, and instead, they've resigned themselves to the traditional team-building blueprint -- pushing all the chips into the middle for one last run and mortgaging their future in the process.

There is no guarantee that Matthews can become the star the organization craves, but the potential is too great and the stakes too high to throw away a golden opportunity in exchange for a chance at short-term glory. For this reason, Brice Matthews must be made untouchable at this year's trade deadline.

More Astros News from Climbing Tal's Hill