The Houston Astros are still somehow sitting in first place in the American League West. Heading into play Wednesday, they lead the Texas Rangers by one game. So there’s still a good chance to see October baseball at Minute Maid Park. But there’s a number that should worry anyone who has watched this roster: 15.
That’s the number of home runs this team has hit in August through play on August 18. It’s a small sample, but certainly big enough to be concerned with a lineup built to hit the ball over the wall. Part of it is that this is a top-heavy team, and the power drought has only made that point sharper.
Yordan Alvarez is still the MVP favorite with 36 home runs and leading all the Triple Crown categories. But a team that leans so hard on him and a couple of others is one that can’t afford any cold stretches from that group, and Alvarez has just one home run since July 28.
The Houston Astros' rotation can't cover for a quiet lineup
Baseball seasons are long. There are ebbs and flows. Sometimes the bats carry the pitchers. Sometimes the pitchers carry the bats. Sometimes they both work. But this team doesn’t have the pitching to carry the bats, at least not in the rotation. Houston’s 5.12 ERA from their starters is third-worst in baseball. Hunter Brown has been solid, but strike-throwing has become a big issue. Peter Lambert has been great, but is coming up on an innings threshold he’s never seen. The rest are…not what you want. There’s likely not a starter you’d truly trust in a Game 3 in October.
That gap also got worse instead of better at the trade deadline. Instead of adding, they traded away Spencer Arrighetti, who was struggling in his own right (and hurt), but he had been so good at one point that he was American League Pitcher of the Month in May. The return was Daulton Varsho, who has the power to help with this issue, but has a .188 SLG in 54 plate appearances since the trade.
Thank goodness for the bullpen. Josh Hader has been automatic, and the Astros rank third in bullpen ERA since June 1. It’s covered for a lot of shaky starts, but asking a bullpen to help erase both a cold offense and an unreliable rotation for weeks in a pennant race is far more hope than plan. There’s simply no margin left for a lineup that goes quiet and for a rotation with only two trustworthy names.
This isn’t to say the season is unraveling. Alvarez covers for a lot and is still one of the most dangerous hitters around. Jeremy Peña and Isaac Paredes are both having very strong years, and the bullpen is one of the better ones in the league. But when you hit just 15 home runs in a month on a team that is capable of doing that in a week, it's the kind of number that leads to far more losses than wins.
Houston has proven it can win some low-scoring games this season, and the fact that they’ve worked their way to the top of the division is proof of that. But October in today’s game generally requires power. It punishes teams that need breaks to fall their way more often than not, and right now the Astros are giving themselves fewer of those breaks than they can afford. It’s fixable, but there isn’t much time left to do it.
