Astros' Silver Slugger finalist nod highlights an encouraging but incomplete offense

Houston Astros' star Yordan Alvarez is in line to win his second Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger award presented by FanSided. The likely AL MVP was named a finalist for the award alongside New York Yankees slugger Ben Rice. One of those two will take home this year's Silver Slugger award as the best designated hitter in the American League.

A side-by-side comparison between the two reveals that Alvarez should be the runaway winner for the honor this year. Alvarez has a higher batting average (.316), on-base percentage (.432), slugging percentage (.601), OPS+ (190), and hit more homers (42) and racked up more RBI (106). This award was tailor made for a player like Alvarez.

But the Astros' DH is the team's only finalist this season (Jeremy Peña had that distinction last year). Some may contend that a players like Peña or Isaac Paredes should've been among nominees, and there's certainly an argument to be made. Interestingly enough, however, the Astros team itself was named a finalist.

This is relatively new category that the folks over at Louisville Slugger have devised. Houston is in the mix with the Yankees, White Sox, and Twins. The Astros led the way among every team in Major League Baseball with 226 home runs this past season. They were also the best in the AL in terms of slugging percentage (.417). Houston had the power department covered.

Astros' Silver Slugger nomination is an honor, but the offense still needs to be tweaked this offseason

The Astros should be thrilled with their Silver Slugger finalist selection, and frankly, they seem to be a strong candidate to win the team award outright once you really look at the raw numbers. But being a finalist doesn't necessarily mean that everything is hunky-dory.

Houston's 734 runs scored ranked fifth among all AL teams and 14th in MLB. In terms of the highest percentage of runs scored via the homer, the Cincinnati Reds led the way with 48.9%. The Astros weren't far behind, however, with 45.8% of their run production coming via the long ball.

That's not to say that hitting home runs is bad; it's not. But when that accounts for nearly half your run production, it can be a feast-or-famine type of scenario. We already mentioned the Reds as one of those teams, and four of the top-10 in that category missed the postseason in 2026. Among them were the Athletics, New York Mets, and Baltimore Orioles. That's not necessarily the type of company you want to keep if you have aspirations of competing for a World Series championship.

But hats off to the Astros' offense — they deserve plenty of praise for their performance last season. Now it's up to new GM Randy Flores and the incoming coaching staff to improve the team's run production while still allowing big boppers like Alvarez to do what they do best.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow