The Houston Astros Best and Worst Investments

3 of 3
Next

Sep 24, 2014; Arlington, TX, USA; Houston Astros second baseman

Jose Altuve

(27) runs to first base during the game against the Texas Rangers at Globe Life Park in Arlington. Mandatory Credit: Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports

The Houston Astros opened up their pocketbooks this offseason, and fans are hoping that this will end up being money well spent, both in 2015, and for the duration of some of these new contracts. Three of this offseason’s new additions made the list that follows, but will they be deemed good values?

Bleacher Report’s Joel Reuter went around the league and compiled each team’s best and worst values based on their projected numbers for 2015. The Houston Astros came in 9th place in Reuter’s “Moneyball” power rankings, which essentially lists each team’s projected win total, what their projected payroll will be, and how much the team spends per win.

The formula he uses for finding player values is relatively simple: (2015 zWAR x 5.5) – 2015 salary = net value. The 5.5 is the estimated value that has been placed on a WAR of 1.0. So, if a player has a WAR of 1.0, that would be worth $5.5M. If that player makes just $4M in 2015, then the net value would be +1.5M.

Simple right? Here is who Reuter came up with from the Astros roster.

Next: 3 Best Values

Sep 10, 2014; Arlington, TX, USA; Los Angeles Angels catcher Hank Conger (24) watches the game from the dugout during the game against the Texas Rangers at Globe Life Park in Arlington. The Angels defeated the Rangers 8-1. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

The three best values on Reuter’s list are Jose Altuve (big surprise here), Jason Castro and Hank Conger. Castro and Conger being added to the list is a bit surprising, but with their contracts being relatively low for the services they provide, it’s certainly understandable.

Let’s start with the AL batting champ, Altuve. Having a player that is in nearly every game, hit .341 a season ago, and is the face of the Houston Astros franchise for just $1.25M is a steal. Oh, he also stole 56 bases in 2014. His contract will be a tad higher in 2015, at $2.688M, but with a projected WAR of 3.6, his projected value is $19.8M, for a net value of +$17.112M. Last season Altuve had a combined WAR of 6.5 according to Baseball Reference, which would be right about double what his 2015 projection is.

After a down season in 2014, Reuter has Jason Castro at a projected WAR of 2.7, which is just slightly higher than his 2.5 (BR) from a year ago. Even with just a slight increase, Castro is considered to be one of the best values on the Astros because he is only making $4M in 2015, which produces a net value of +$10.85. If Castro has a season closer to his 2013 campaign, he’ll challenge Altuve for the biggest bargain of the bunch.

Finally, Hank Conger comes in with a projected WAR of 1.2, which is slightly lower than the 1.4 that he put up in 2014. That works out to a projected value of $6.6M, with his actual 2015 salary being $1.075M. Carry the one, and you get a net value of +$5.525M. Conger’s defense was responsible for more than half of his WAR last season, but playing in Minute Maid Park could help awaken his bat just enough to help his offensive WAR climb a bit.

Next: 3 Worst Values

Sep 24, 2014; Arlington, TX, USA; Houston Astros starting pitcher Scott Feldman (46) throws during the game against the Texas Rangers at Globe Life Park in Arlington. Mandatory Credit: Kevin Jairaj-USA TODAY Sports

The first name on the list shouldn’t come as much of a surprise: Scott Feldman. Don’t get me wrong, Feldman did a commendable job last season, but pitchers have a harder time accumulating WAR as it is, and with his $10M salary in 2015, his projected negative value makes sense. Reuter has Feldman at a projected WAR of 1.0, which works out to a projected value of $5.5M, and a net loss of -$4.5M.

The next two names won’t make many fans happy, but keep in mind that as hard as it is for starting pitchers to accumulate WAR, it’s even harder for relief pitchers. That’s where Luke Gregerson and Pat Neshek come in. Neshek has a projected WAR of 0.4, which amounts to a projected value of $2.2M. Couple that with his 2015 income of $5.5M, and we’re left with a net projected loss of -$3.3M.

It’s a pretty similar outcome for Gregerson, who is projected at a WAR of 0.5, or a value of $2.75M. Again, that leads to a net loss, but this time of -$3.25M. Gregerson’s WAR last season was 1.7, so the projection has him falling off quite a bit. The same goes for Neshek, who accumulated a 2.3 WAR in 2014.

While the bullpen is projected to be a bad investment, I’m doubting many Astros fans are feeling that way. In this case, it’s not about wins above replacement, but how many leads make it to the ninth inning.

Next: Roster Predictions: Starting Pitchers

More from Climbing Tal's Hill

Next