The Houston Astros need to make a decision on the future of Jeremy Peña. He is one of the best shortstops in the game and has one year left of team control before he becomes a free agent. Even though the Astros have only missed the playoffs twice in the last 12 years, it seems like their time in the sun is fading if they don't navigate the next 12 months correctly.
Owner Jim Crane's self-imposed contract limit has resulted in multiple star players from the championship teams leaving in free agency. While the organization finally made the correct move of trading outfielder Kyle Tucker before he did the same, they now need to make a similar choice on Pena.
While getting the 29-year-old to sign a long-term extension is the ideal scenario, it seems unlikely given what Crane has been willing to hand out in the past for one of the best shortstops in the game. That leaves two choices, and one should be the obvious choice: trade him or see him leave in free agency. Even with playoff aspirations for the 2027 season, allowing Peña to walk next offseason to get a compensatory pick is clearly the wrong choice. Then the question becomes: where could they trade him?
Multiple teams are reportedly scouring the trade market for upgrades at shortstop this offseason, but one stands out. The Los Angeles Dodgers haven't publicly announced a need at shortstop, but there are constant rumors connecting them to the major shortstops on the trade market this offseason, except Peña, and he should be the one they are targeting the most.
The Dodgers and Astros don't make trades often, but this is one the Astros should be pushing for
In the group of Peña, Elly De La Cruz, Zach Neto, and CJ Abrams, Peña has the least team control. While that could seem like a negative, the Dodgers don't need someone who will be around for a couple of years. Peña is probably the second-best overall shortstop in the group behind De La Cruz, but his value is probably closer to the bottom because of his lack of team control.
L.A. should prefer Peña as a solid bat and solid defender over the other options because they don't need the upside of the other players. They have the big bats in their lineup, and while Peña is certainly no slouch at the plate, he is also a very sure-handed defender.
By trading for him, the Dodgers would also get first cracks at getting him to sign a long-term contract if they wanted to keep him around. It will be a big deal, but the Dodgers won't be scared of that, and it might be smaller than the others, too.
Trading a star player to the Dodgers is never something any baseball fan outside L.A. wants to see, especially Astros fans. The Dodgers' always impressive farm system should have Randy Flores at least keeping the phone line open to hear them out.
The Astros really can't go into the 2027 season with Peña still on the roster if they aren't going to extend him. Once the season starts, his value is only going to fall, and that only hurts what the organization will be able to do in the future. The Dodgers should be a team the Astros are talking to as a trade partner for Peña before the season starts; it just makes too much sense.
