Skip to main content

Astros fans may not like it, but Brad Ausmus was the right managerial hire

ByJimmy Price
Nov 13, 2026; Houston, TX, USA;  Houston Astros manager Brad Ausmus and general manager Randy Flores pose for a picture during a press conference at Daiken Park in Houston, TX.  Mandatory Credit: Erik Williams-Imagn Images
Nov 13, 2026; Houston, TX, USA; Houston Astros manager Brad Ausmus and general manager Randy Flores pose for a picture during a press conference at Daiken Park in Houston, TX. Mandatory Credit: Erik Williams-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The title might be fighting words around Houston, but there is a real case that the Houston Astros made the right decision in hiring Brad Ausmus as their next manager. While his previous managerial record and connection to Jeff Bagwell have raised concerns among fans, his experience, baseball knowledge and time spent learning from different organizations make him the right choice for Houston.

There is plenty of skepticism surrounding the Ausmus hire, mainly because of his potential connection to Bagwell's influence within the organization. Astros fans have every right to feel that way. However, when looking at Ausmus' background and experience, he was deserving of another opportunity to manage.

Brad Ausmus may not be perfect, but that doesn't mean he doesn't bring anything to the table as their new manager

During his playing career, which included parts of 10 seasons with the Astros, there was a general belief that Ausmus would eventually become a manager. After retiring following the 2010 season, he joined the Padres' front office as a special assistant to the general manager. In that role, he worked in player evaluation, instruction and assessment through 2013.

Ausmus got his first opportunity to manage in 2014 when he was named manager of the Detroit Tigers. In his first season, Detroit went 90-72 and won the AL Central. However, the success didn't last, and Ausmus finished his four-year tenure with a 314-332 record. His next opportunity came with the Angels in 2019, but that lasted just one season following a 72-90 finish.

Astros fans should understand better than most that a manager's first opportunity doesn't always define his career. A.J. Hinch had an 89-123 record with the Arizona Diamondbacks before coming to Houston, and we all know how that turned out. That doesn't mean Ausmus will have the same success, but it does show why judging a manager solely on his previous record can be misleading.

After his time with the Angels, Ausmus spent the 2022 season as the bench coach for the Oakland Athletics before joining the Yankees in the same role in 2024. His time in New York gave him another opportunity to work within an organization that faces enormous pressure to win every season. That experience should be valuable as he takes over an Astros team with similar expectations.

When joining the Yankees, Ausmus also discussed the importance of balancing analytics with the human element of managing, which is an important quality in today's game. Analytics play a major role in baseball, but managers still need communicate effectively and know how to get the most out of the talent on their roster.

The Astros are also entering a different era than the one that produced seven consecutive ALCS appearances. The roster has weaknesses, younger players will need opportunities to develop, and the organization is trying to remain competitive while building for the future. The next manager needs to be able to handle those challenges while maintaining a winning culture. I believe Ausmus has the experience and background to navigate that transition.

Now, with that said, Morgan Ensberg would have been a good hire as well. Ensberg has worked in the minor league system as a manager for years and has experience developing young players. Given the organization's need to get more contributions from its farm system, one can understand the argument for hiring him.

Albert Pujols could have worked out, too. While he has less managerial experience, that doesn't necessarily mean he wouldn't have been successful. There have been plenty of managers who have found success without extensive experience in the role.

However, what separates Ausmus for me is the combination of major league managerial experience, front office experience and time spent as a bench coach. He has seen the game from nearly every angle, and that gives him an advantage as the Astros look to remain competitive while transitioning into a new era.

The Ausmus hire was always going to be polarizing given Bagwell's influence within the organization. Those concerns are fair and understandable, but Ausmus deserves to be judged on his own merits rather than his connections to people in the Astros' front office.

Ultimately, Randy Flores and the Astros have made their decision, and there is still a real chance that they made a good one. Ausmus brings a wealth of baseball experience and has had opportunities to learn from both his successes and failures throughout his career. Whether that translates into success in Houston remains to be seen. Only time will tell.

Add us as a preferred source on Google