Astros Roster Predictions: The Bullpen
Mar 2, 2015; Kissimmee, FL, USA; Houston Astros relief pitcher Luke Gregerson (44) simulates throwing off the mound during morning work outs at Osceola County Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Tommy Gilligan-USA TODAY Sports
In our last piece in the Astros roster predictions for Opening Day, it’s for potentially the biggest factor to success this season: the bullpen. We all broke down the main candidates for closer, along with three others who will be on the team. The last two spots though definitely revealed some interesting names.
Closer
We were pretty much split right down the middle, and it’s down to two men: Luke Gregerson and Chad Qualls.
Ryan Gonzalez
Luke Gregerson: This isn’t an easy choice as I could legitimately see Qualls, Neshek, or Fields in this role. But the Astros paid Gregerson some money and believe in him being able to finish out games. He’ll be given the opportunity early, but there will be many others who can step in and take over if he fails.
Brian Del Castillo
Luke Gregerson: Ever since we signed Gregerson and Neshek, I assumed that Qualls would be our 7th inning man, Neshek the 8th inning, and Gregerson the closer.
Kennon Riley
Chad Qualls
Thomas O’Banion
Gregerson seems like the choice to be the closer, but it is possible that they start with a closer by committee until someone proves themselves comfortable in that role.
Eric Huysman
Luke Gregerson: With the money the Astros spent on Luke Gregerson, he will be given the chance to succeed where he has failed in the past. Should he struggle, Chad Qualls will get next opportunity. Josh Fields would be third in line to close.
Issa Cook
Qualls with a switch to Gregerson if he starts off poorly.
Jason Burke
Chad Qualls earned the spot with his performance last season, but his leash could be short with many more options to go with this season. The Astros put some incentives into Gregerson’s contract if he closes out games, but those could amount to being a carrot on a stick.
Verdict: Luke Gregerson will be the CTH Astros closer going into the season by a 4-3 vote.
Next: The Group of 3
Mar 2, 2015; Kissimmee, FL, USA; Houston Astros relief pitcher Josh Fields (35) throws during morning work outs at Osceola County Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Tommy Gilligan-USA TODAY Sports
The Group of Three
Tony Sipp, Pat Neshek, and Josh Fields received unanimous votes for being on the team from the entire CTH staff. So let’s break each down briefly.
*Luke Gregerson and Chad Qualls aren’t part of this particular list since they were on the previous slide, even though they both received unanimous votes. They will be on the team as well.
Pat Neshek: As soon as he was signed, Astros fans knew he’d play a big part in the bullpen. He’s another potential closer candidate, but will probably be used in tight situations in the later innings
Josh Fields: Yet another closer candidate on the team, and he’s somebody that I want to close out games. This would mean that Qualls, Gregerson, Neshek, and Sipp could be used in escaping jams leading into the ninth inning, something they all excel in.
Tony Sipp: He was extremely valuable in his role coming out of the bullpen last season and getting the team out of trouble at any point in the game. Expect for him to have a very similar role this season.
Now let’s take at the final two bullpen spots on the team.
Next: The Final Two
Sep 28, 2014; Seattle, WA, USA; Los Angeles Angels relief pitcher Joe Thatcher (54) pitches to the Seattle Mariners during the fourth inning at Safeco Field. Mandatory Credit: Steven Bisig-USA TODAY Sports
The Final Two
We were all over the place here as some produced a long reliever, others did not. Now let’s break it down.
Ryan Gonzalez
Will Harris: I’ve mentioned before the way Jeff Luhnow spoke about Harris at the bloggers roundtable, and it’s for that reason alone that I expect him to be on the Opening Day roster as long as he doesn’t have a terrible spring.
Joe Thatcher: I believe Thatcher will make the team to be the only lefty specialist on the team. Yes, Sipp is a lefty as well, but he’s used against both types of hitters. This leaves me with saying there won’t be a long reliever on the team. The only reason I feel that way is because of how the rotation should perform this season.
Brian Del Castillo
Joe Thatcher: A lefty out of the bullpen
Asher Wojciechowski: The “loser” of the 5th rotation spot
Kennon Riley
Will Harris and Jake Buchanan
Thomas O’Banion
Dan Straily and Joe Thatcher
Issa Cook
Joe Thatcher and Brad Peacock
Eric Huysman
Will Harris and Joe Thatcher: As Ryan mentioned above, the Astros are high on Will Harris. Harris was claimed by the Astros from the Arizona Diamondbacks, which was labeled a steal at the bloggers roundtable at Fan Fest. I like Thatcher as a compliment to Pat Neshek’s delivery.
Jason Burke
Joe Thatcher because he is a proven, veteran bullpen arm that could be very useful on this team. I’m going with Straily as the long-relief option with Brad Peacock making the team as the fifth starter. If Peacock isn’t ready for Opening Day, Straily will likely be in the rotation, and that opens up a whole can of worms. I’m going to be optimistic and say Peacock will be healthy.
Verdict: Joe Thatcher (six votes) and Will Harris (three votes) will fill out the bullpen, which would leave the Astros without a long reliever. Part of it was four different pitchers being voted in as a long relief candidate, but the Astros very well might not need one this year. This brings our Opening Day roster predictions to a close, and make sure to come by tomorrow to check out the final CTH 25 man roster.
You can check out the other predictions below:
Catcher and Designated Hitter
First Base and Second Base
Third Base and Shortstop
Outfield
Starting Rotation
Next: The Astros Announce Spring Training Rotation
More from Climbing Tal's Hill
- Just how much better is the Houston Astros playoff rotation than the rest?
- Houston Astros: A Lineup Change to Spark Offense
- Astros prospect Hunter Brown throws 6 shutout innings in debut
- Always faithful Astros World Series champion Josh Reddick defends the title
- Michael Conforto declines Astros’ 2-year, $30 million offer